Johann Tetzel
Johann Tetzel was born in Saxony about 1465, studied at Leipzig, and entered the Dominican order in 1489. He rose to be prior and inquisitor, and for more than a decade before 1517 he made his living as a professional preacher of indulgences, traveling, as Merle d’Aubigné describes him, in a fine carriage with mounted attendants and a salary that his perquisites “far exceeded.”1
In January 1517 Archbishop Albrecht of Mainz made him subcommissioner for the indulgence that Leo X had proclaimed for the rebuilding of St. Peter’s. Half the proceeds in Albrecht’s lands were to repay the Fugger bank. Frederick the Wise barred Tetzel from Electoral Saxony, but he preached at Jüterbog, just over the border, and Luther’s parishioners went there to buy. A cross bearing the papal arms was raised in the church, and Tetzel promised the crowd that the dead were waiting on their coins:
“At the very instant,” continued Tezel, “when the piece of money chinks on the bottom of the strong box, the soul comes out of purgatory, and, set free, flies upward into heaven.”1 Johann Tetzelas reported by Merle d’Aubigné
Luther’s Ninety-Five Theses of October 31, 1517, were aimed squarely at this preaching. Tetzel answered with 106 counter-theses, composed by Konrad Wimpina and defended at Frankfurt an der Oder in January 1518, and Wittenberg students burned copies of them in the market square. His victory was short. In 1519 the papal envoy Karl von Miltitz made him the scapegoat for the whole affair, rebuking him for extravagance and immorality. Tetzel withdrew to the Dominican house at Leipzig, where he died on August 11, 1519.
The man he had provoked was the only one who pitied him. “I pity Tezel,” Luther wrote to Spalatin, and he sent the dying friar a letter of comfort.2 He had hated the traffic, not the trafficker.
A note for preachers: the jingle “As soon as the coin in the coffer rings, the soul from purgatory springs” is not found in Tetzel’s own writings. Luther cites it in Thesis 27 as what was being preached, and contemporaries attributed it to Tetzel. His own published theses did teach that an indulgence for the dead required no contrition of the buyer, which was the substance of Luther’s complaint.

